More Americans Will Rely on Debt and Pay Later Plans this Holiday Season, Shows Survey

Small Business | July 28, 2025

More Americans Will Rely on Debt and Pay Later Plans this Holiday Season, Shows Survey

Nearly half (47%) of respondents anticipate spending the most on holiday purchases in 2025 with Amazon, other big box retailers like Walmart, Target, etc. (32%), Black Friday/Cyber Monday (25%), and 18% with small businesses.

Isaac M. O'Bannon

a leading invoice template software designed to meet the invoicing needs of small businesses, freelancers, and entrepreneurs worldwide today released its second annual “Holiday Spending” Survey, revealing the impact the U.S. economy will have on consumer spending this holiday season.

New data shows that many Americans will prioritize gifting this holiday season, no matter the impact to their wallets. One-third (37%) said that buying gifts is more important than a credit card balance this season, and that they planned to use debt or pay later plans for the holidays. That’s according to the second annual “Holiday Spending” survey, commissioned by invoice template vendor Invoice Home, and conducted with third-party research firm Censuswide.

Navigating spending

25 percent of U.S. consumers plan to use Buy Now, Pay Later (BNPL) services to navigate holiday spending this year, followed by ChatGPT/AI (16%). Gen Z (20%) and Millennial (19%) respondents in particular plan to cover holiday expenses in 2025 by leveraging BNPL services. Other ways include:

  • 27% of Millennials plan to go into credit card debt (2024 -21%)
  • 40% of Gen Z plan to dip into savings (2024 -32%)

To make ends meet during the season, these generations are willing to delay bill payments by:

  • 2-3 weeks – 26% Gen Z, 30% Millennials
  • 1-2 months – 10% Gen Z, 16% Millennials

If prices continue to increase due to inflation/external economic factors, Gen Z and Millennials will also consider the following to save money during the holidays:

  • Not travel – 46% Gen Z, 30% Millennials
  • Opt out of gifting – 30% Gen Z, 27% Millennials
  • Thrift gifts – 38% Gen Z, 26% Millennials
  • Push celebrating the holiday to 2026 when it’s less expensive – 16% Gen Z, 16% Millennials

“This data shows that consumers aren’t shifting away from spending but being strategic in how they spend and in how they’ll afford the season,” said Petr Marek, Co-Founder and CEO at Invoice Home. “With rising costs being out of many businesses’ controls, now is the time to ensure your customer experience is flawless from the moment they begin interacting with you. Look for avenues to connect with your customer like providing financing options or suggesting alternate products to ones that aren’t available or out of their price range. Small acts like this can be the difference between a sale and moving onto your competitor.”

How and where consumers are spending

Last year consumers were asked the same question – what would make someone not shop with a retailer during the holiday season. This year, trends show this is more important than ever to pay attention to. U.S. consumers will not shop with a retailer this holiday season if: 

  • An increase in prices overall (2024 -25%) – 50%
  • An increase in cost to return (2024 -11%) – 25%
  • Poor experience with a shipping carrier the retailer used (2024 -11%) – 23%
  • Poor communication from around delayed shipping (2024 -10%) – 22%

Competing on cost is one of the greatest challenges for a brand/business but there are several tactics to incentivize purchases. If a brand/business isn’t offering a discount at the time of purchase during the holidays, 42% would still feel incentivized to buy if free shipping/returns was offered, along with reward/loyalty points (34%), gift with purchase (28%) and the promise of a discount code for the next order (19%).

Nearly half (47%) of respondents anticipate spending the most on holiday purchases in 2025 with Amazon, other big box retailers like Walmart, Target, etc. (32%), Black Friday/Cyber Monday (25%), and 18% with small businesses. Nearly 1 in 5 (18%) Gen Z anticipate spending the most with TikTok Shop. 

Thanks for reading CPA Practice Advisor!

Subscribe for free to get personalized daily content, newsletters, continuing education, podcasts, whitepapers and more…

Leave a Reply